- Journal Issues
- № 1-2 2020 Actual problems of criminal justice
- Problems of criminal procedure
- Ensuring the effectiveness of criminal proceedings as one aspect of the functional purpose of the subject matter
Ensuring the effectiveness of criminal proceedings as one aspect of the functional purpose of the subject matter
Review
The article deals with one of the aspects of the functional purpose of the object of knowledge, which is to ensure the effectiveness of criminal proceedings. Attention is drawn to the fact that the investigations are subject to ways of ensuring the effectiveness of criminal proceedings related to the distribution of the subject matter of the subjects of criminal proceedings.
Taking into account the stated purpose of the article, a study was carried out to ensure the effectiveness of criminal proceedings as one of the aspects of the functional purpose of the subject of knowledge due to the analysis of theoretical points of view regarding the functional purpose of the object of knowledge; identifying ways of ensuring the effectiveness of criminal proceedings related to the distribution of the subject matter of the subjects of criminal proceedings.
Based on the analysis of different theoretical positions of scientists, it is concluded that the common in the functional purpose of the subject of control of the subjects of criminal proceedings is to ensure the efficiency of the proceedings, to ensure the rights of participants, to ensure legality, and so on. It is suggested that a higher level of competence should be held by a more knowledgeable and qualified lawyer. Among the subjects of the prosecution, it can be noted that the prosecutor takes a leading position with respect to the investigator, respectively, performs more qualified and more responsible work relative to the latter. The prosecutor is subject to a higher level of competence with respect to the investigator, and it would therefore be logical to present higher qualification requirements to candidates for the exercise of this function.
It is concluded that ensuring the effectiveness of criminal proceedings in connection with the distribution of the subject matter is through: 1) the division of labor between subjects of the same level, which promotes their skills and more organized production process; 2) division of labor between the executing entities and the authorities, which facilitates the organization of criminal proceedings; 3) the distribution of control and evaluation of the results of criminal proceedings by certain subjects of jurisdiction.
Keywords: subject matter, competence, subject of criminal proceedings, functional purpose, effectiveness of criminal proceedings.
REFERENCES BIBLIOGRAPHY AUTHORED BOOKS- Lobojko L, Kryminaljno-procesualjna kompetencija: monoghrafija [Criminal procedural competence: monograph] (Dnipropetrovsjk, Dnipropetrovsjkyj derzhavnyj universytet vnutrishnikh sprav 2006) 188 [in Ukranian].
- Dyurkgeym E, O razdelenii obshchestvennogo truda. Metod sotsiologii [On the division of social labor. Sociology method] (Moskva, Nauka 1990) 575 [in Russian].
- Selyutin A, ’Podsledstvennost, kak forma vneshnego vyrazheniya razgranicheniya kompetentsii gosudarstvennykh organov i dolzhnostnykh lits pri osushchestvlenii ugolovno-protsessual’noy deyatel’nosti’ [Jurisdiction as a form of external expression of delineation of competence of state bodies and officials in the implementation of criminal procedure] (2010) 1 Probely v rossiyskom zakonodatel’stve 171–174 [in Russian].
- Kuzjmenko O, ’Naukovyj menedzhment jak skladova procesu derzhavnogho upravlinnja’ [Scientific management as a component of public administration process] (2007) 6 Vlada. Ljudyna. Zakon. 45–48 [in Ukranian].
- Ghmyrko V, ’Dijaljnisnyj poghljad na restrukturizaciju kryminaljnogho procesu: The attempt of dogmatic shawshank redemption?’ [Actual view of criminal process restructuring: The attempt of dogmatic shawshank redemption?] (2018) 1 (20) Pravova pozycija 21–36 [in Ukranian].
- Kuba N, Topolevsjkyj R, ’Systema ocinky efektyvnosti roboty Nacionaljnoji policiji’ [National Police Performance Assessment System] Informacija z sajta: Prava Ljudyny v Ukrajini. Informacijnyj portal Kharkivsjkoji pravozakhysnoji ghrupy 15.02.2016 <http://khpg.org/index.php?id=1455530110> data zvernennja 10.02.2020 [in Ukranian].
- Overchuk S, ’Ponjattja ta vydy pidsudnosti u kryminaljnomu procesi Ukrajiny’ [Concepts and types of jurisdiction in the criminal process of Ukraine] (dys kand yuryd nauk, Kyjiv 2005) 244 [in Ukranian].
- Omarov A, ’Instytut pidslidnosti v kryminaljnomu provadzhenni’ [Institute for the Jurisdiction of Criminal Proceedings] (dys kand yuryd nauk, Kharkiv 2017) 214 [in Ukranian].
- Jeremenko Ju, ’Pravovi ta orghanizacijni osnovy specializaciji orghaniv prokuratury v Ukrajini’ [Legal and organizational bases of specialization of prosecuting authorities in Ukraine] (dys kand yuryd nauk, Kyjiv 2019) 279 [in Ukranian].
- Botvinov R, ’Kryminaljna procesualjna kompetencija kerivnyka orghanu dosudovogho rozsliduvannja (za materialamy dijaljnosti slidchykh pidrozdiliv orghaniv, shho zdijsnjujutj kontrolj za doderzhannjam podatkovogho zakonodavstva)’ [Criminal procedural competence of the head of the pre-trial investigation body (based on the materials of the activity of the investigative divisions of the bodies, which control the observance of tax legislation)] (dys kand yuryd nauk, Donecjk 2013) 208 [in Ukranian].
- Kozeracjka O, ’Pidslidnistj kryminaljnykh provadzhenj zlochyniv proty bezpeky vyrobnyctva na dosudovomu rozsliduvanni’ [Consistency of criminal proceedings against the safety of production at pretrial investigation] Materialy 69-ji naukovoji konferenciji profesorsjko-vykladacjkogho skladu ekonomikopravovogho fakuljtetu Odesjkogho nac. universytetu im. I.I. Mechnykova (Odesa, Astroprynt 2014) 106–109 [in Ukranian].