Review

This article is devoted to an analysis of the status of victims of international crimes in international criminal law with particular reference to those victims who have been harmed in different regions of Ukraine (Kyiv, Crimea, Eastern Ukraine) since 21 November 2013. In other words, the author conducts a concise analysis of who can qualify as a victim of international crimes as well as of what set of rights such a victim possesses in proceedings before the International Criminal Court (ICC). These general remarks, in turn, are subsequently situated in the wider perspective of the so-called Ukrainian case.

It is argued that for a long time victims of international crimes have been forgotten subjects of international criminal trials. The situation has only changed gradually with the development of international criminal law since the Nuremberg trials until 1998 when the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC) was adopted. Nowadays, victims’ procedural rights are expanding as, in fact, are definitions of victimhood provided for in various international legal documents (i. e. definition of victims of crime included in rule 85 of the Rules of Procedure and Evidence of the ICC). It follows that both natural persons and legal persons can qualify as victims of crime in proceedings before the International Criminal Court. Apart from that, also the concept of an international crime is subject to certain controversies which cannot be solved by a mere reference to legal definitions or texts. Therefore, it is argued that international crimes should be differentiated from ordinary offences due to their different normative source and the specific context of the commission of these crimes. Moreover, the author also criticizes non-legal (moral) justifications underlying the differentiation between international and ordinary crimes. In part IV, in turn, the current status of the ’Ukrainian situation’ before the International Criminal Court is examined. The author concludes the substantive part with cataloguing the list of procedural rights that victims of international crimes have been equipped with together with the adoption of the ICC’s Rome Statute and which, potentially, can be acquired by victims of international crimes that have been committed during the Ukrainian crisis.

References

1. 1. Kodeks postępowania karnego: Ustawa RP z dnia 6 czerwca 1997 r. (1997) data leczenia 01.03.2018 (in Poland).
2. Victim Charter, A Charter for victims of crime (2015) accessed 01.03.2018 (in English).
3. Rules of Procedure and Evidence of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (1994) 11 (in English).
4. 1 Królikowski M. Podstawy prawa karnego międzynarodowego (Warszawa 2008) 394.
5. Hoegen E, ’Victims of crime in 22 European criminal justice systems, The Implementation of Recommendation’ (85) 11 of the Council of Europe on the Position of the Victim in the Framework of Criminal Law and Procedure (Nijmegen 2003) 1208 (in English).
6. Fernandez de Casadevante Romanis C, International Law of Victims (Heidelberg-New York-DordrechtLondon Heidelberg-Dordrecht-London 2012) 279 (in English).
7. Nash A, ’Victims by Definition’ (2008) 85 Washington University Law Review 1419–1461 (in English).
8. Drumbl M A, ’Victims who victimise’ (2016) 4(2) London Review of International Law 217–246 (in English).
9. Gizbert-Studnicki T, Język prawny a obraz świata Prawo w zmieniającym się społeczeństwie. Księga Jubileuszowa Profesor Marii Boruckiej-Arctowej (Kraków 1992) 566 (in Poland).
10. Fletcher G, The Grammar of Criminal Law. American, Comparative and International (Oxford-New York 2007) 43–58 (in English).
11. Marchuk I, The Fundamental Concept of Crime in International Criminal Law. A Comparative Analysis (Heidelberg New York Dordrecht London 2014) 92–111 (in English).
12. Płachta M. Międzynarodowy Trybunał Karny. Tom I. (Zakamycze 2004) 1752 (in Poland).
13. ICC: Report on Preliminary Examination Activities (2017) 74 (in English).
14. Cançado Trindade A A, The Access of Individuals to International Justice (Oxford-New York 2011) 201–204 (in English).
15. Królikowski M, Podstawy prawa karnego międzynarodowego (Warszawa 2008) 394 (in Poland).