- Journal Issues
- № 4, (2016) Actual problems of criminal justice
- Problems of the criminal process
- Types of visual monitoring in criminal proceedings
Types of visual monitoring in criminal proceedings
Keywords
Review
The article is dedicated to the analysis of the provisions of the Article 269 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine and to the determination of the grounds for classifying visual monitoring as a
covert investigative (search) action on individual species. From this perspective, the legislator introduced evaluates criteria differentiating visual monitoring. The copyright vision of approaches to the
definition in the norms of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine different kinds of visual monitoring
are given. The promising ways of legal, organizational and tactical measures of each species are
outlined.
It was determined that the Article 269 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine introduces unjustified legal classification of the covert investigative (search) actions for certain types depending on
the nature and number of objects which is monitoring, and used means. Thus, the conflicts and gaps
that lead to problems in practice activity of the pre-trial investigations bodies and operative subdivisions, acting on behalf of investigator or prosecutor, are formed.
The rules of this article should be formulated otherwise: using the differentiation of the individuals
which are the subject of monitoring on known (established, identified) and unknown (not established,
not identified). In addition, visual monitoring need to differentiate is being done by voluntary agreement and persons without such consent. Each type of visual monitoring should receive some using
procedural grounds. The distinction between surveillance of an individual, an object or a place is not justified not only
in legal but also in organizational and tactical plan. That why, it is advisable to allocate surveillance
from permanent positions (stationary) and the surveillance in movement (movable).
References
- Кримінальний процесуальний кодекс України від 13 квіт. 2012 р. [Електронний ресурс] //
- Офіц. веб-сайт Верховної Ради України. – Режим доступу: http://zakon1.rada.gov.ua.
- Зовнішнє спостереження: історія та сучасність. Збірник документів та матеріалів: навч. посіб.
- / Відп. ред. О. Н. Ярмиш; упоряд.: В. М. Чисніков, Т. О. Проценко, С. Г. Лаптєв; передмова і коментарі
- В. М. Чиснікова. – К.: «МП Леся», 2009. – 664 с.
- Becker Ronald F. Dutelle Aric W. Criminal Investigation / F. Becker Ronald, W. Dutelle Aric. –
- Burlington, MA: Jones & Bartlett Learning, 2012. – 576 с.
- Hess Kären M. Criminal Іnvestigation / M. Hess Kären, H. Orthmann Christine. – Clifton Park, NY:
- Delmar, 2013. – 761 с.
- Hess Kären M. Criminal Іnvestigation / M. Hess Kären, H. Orthmann Christine. – Cliftin Park, NY:
- Cengage Learning, 2012. – 752 с.
- Swanson Charles R. Criminal Investigation / R. Swanson Charles, C. Chamelin Neil, L. Territo. –
- Boston: McGraw Hill, 2000. – 800 с.
- Константинов А. Наружное наблюдение: Экипаж. Ребус / А. Константинов. – М.: АСТ, 2009. –
- с.
- Черкасов Д. Пятая стража [Электронный ресурс] / Д. Черкасов. – Режим доступа: http://www.
- phantastike.ru/cherkasov.
- Тайная стража; Тайная стража: смертельные игры – [художественный фильм] – Кинокомпания
- «Эхо» [Электронный ресурс] / режиссёр Ю. Музыка, сценарий В. Шмакова, В. Романова. – 2005. – Ре-
- жим доступа: http://serialu.net/tajnaja-strazha/.
- Топтуны ‒ [художественный фильм] – Кинокомпания «Star Media» [Электронный ресурс] /
- режиссёры С. Артимович, С. Векслер, сценарий С. Кузьминых. – 2012. – Режим доступа: https://www.
- kinopoisk.ru/film/592111/.